Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliners in 2020 (Reviews & Buyer’s Guide)

Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliners
We are supported by readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Eyeliner is one of the most commonly found pieces of makeup with women, and also, probably it can also be said to be the most versatile form of makeup accessory. No matter the look you are aiming for, a dash of eyeliner will almost certainly always take it a step ahead. For all it is worth, an eyeliner has never been accorded due credit for its usability.

For all the eyeliners being the humble part of your makeup kit, they still demand extreme care in regards to the features you need to be looking out for. It needs to be smudge-free, smear-proof, waterproof, and also preferably, cruelty-free. Cruelty-free products are still not being heralded with as much popularity, but the process is still in its middle steps, and cruelty-free brands are emerging one by one.

We have here made a list of some of the best cruelty-free eyeliners, many of which are also vegan. Read on to find out our top 15 picks for the cruelty free eyeliners in the market, which we think are going to be the best pick for your makeup accessories.

15 Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliners in 2020

1. Overall Best: Burt's Bees Nourishing Eyeliner

The Burt’s Bees Eyeliner tends to glide on the skin of the customer almost effortlessly so that you are able to get that defined eye without much hassle. Keeping in mind the need of the people with the delicate eyes, this Nourishing Eyeliner can latch on to your skin and stays so without any creasing or wearing of the skin for the customer. A fine pick, if it can be said.

  • It does not fade easily, smudge-proof formula.
  • Available in 3 different shades.
  • It contains natural ingredients – Jojoba, Mango, and Meadowfoam Seed oil.

Check On Amazon

2. Best Cruelty Free Liquid Eyeliner: NYX Professional Matte

This Matte Liquid Eyeliner from NYX comes from its professional line of cosmetic products. The Matte Liquid Eyeliner is your perfect choice if you want that winged eyeline flawlessly since it comes with a precision brush that can be used for ultra-fine precision lines. The matte-black formula used here is perfect for control over the lines you draw, and all of it will remain smudge-proof after application.

  • Precision design – perfect for flawless eyelines.
  • Brush tip – for further refined designs.
  • Smudge-proof formula.

Check On Amazon

3. Best Brown Liquid Eyeliner: Pacifica Beauty Natural

The Pacifica Beauty Eye Pencil is a natural product, constituted with most of nature’s goodness. The buttery smooth application enables the customer to apply it easily, and bring out the beauty enhanced further. To add on to it, it is available in 3 different shades, so let it be your pick. It is a completely vegan and cruelty-free product. Best brown liquid eyeliner.

  • It contains natural ingredients – shea butter, Vitamin E & C, Jojoba Oil.
  • No harmful ingredients used.
  • Free of paraben, phthalates, etc.

Check On Amazon

4. Best Drugstore Eye Pencil: Physicians Formula Eye Booster

Healthy Beauty is a concept that Physician’s Formula aspires to provide to their customers, and this Eyeliner works just like that. The Eye Booster Formula here enhances the base of the eyelashes and boosts their look a bit higher. The formula is good for the lashes, as it constantly nourishes and conditions them from their roots. The product is cruelty-free, of course, and is also safe for those who wear contact lenses or have sensitive skin. An all-round package of goodness, indeed.

  • Hypoallergenic product – safe for sensitive eyes.
  • Smooth application on the eyes.
  • It does not include over 150 known harmful substances.

Check On Amazon

5. Best Vegan Eyeliner: Milani Infinite Everlast

This product is one of the most lasting eyeliners on the list and can last a whole day after it has been applied. With the added bonus that it is also smudge-proof and does not smear on the skin, it becomes a really good option that you can go for. The product is also waterproof, so sweating or mild water will not be sufficient to wash it away – you’re safe there.

  • Precision tip to alter the depth and thickness of the lines.
  • Vegan product certified cruelty-free.
  • It comes in vibrant shades.

Check On Amazon

6. Organic Waterproof Eyeliner: NYX Epic Ink Liner

This Ink Liner from NYX is a good option you could look for if you desire the precision in your eyeliner. Coming from the Professional Makeup Line from Nyx, this Ink Liner is a Matte Liquid Liner which comes in a design which is made so as to enhance the precision of the user and bring out the beauty of a well-defined eye. The result is a long-lasting look which does not smear easily – totally worth it.

  • Cruelty-free product.
  • Ultra-precise and flexible application tip.
  • Long-lasting, smudge-proof design.

Check On Amazon

7. Best Drugstore Eye Pencil Covergirl Perfect Point Plus

The Covergirl Perfect Point Eyeliner relies on the application with a small point-shaped tip which allows you to smoothly apply and make a fine line, as precisely as you want to. So as to stay on top of it, the product has an inherent sharpener, which does not allow the tip to become blunt and create undesired smudges. As an added bonus, it also does come in several other shades, so that you can have the variety as you want.

  • It contains a smudger, to allow the liner to blend in.
  • Cruelty-free product.
  • Self-sharpening tip.

Check On Amazon

8. Organic Waterproof Eyeliner: Marcelle Metal Green

With the rising humidity, it is important to have an eyeliner that will be waterproof so that sweat doesn’t come in the way of ruining your look. This is a perfect choice. A creamy formula that will not smudge along with staying put all day; Marcelle eyeliners are definitely a must-try.

  • Hypoallergenic and fragrance-free liners.
  • Waterproof along with long-lasting effects.
  • It resists heat and stays put in humid weather.

Check On Amazon

9. Best Natural Liquid Eyeliner: W3LL People Natural Expressionist

Created with premium quality natural and organic ingredients, The W3LL People liquid eyeliner is totally safe for your skin. If you don’t want your liner to smudge, or don’t want it flake-and-fade in no manner whatsoever, close your eyes and go for this. It won’t disappoint in any of these expectations. With its effective plant-based formulas, you should be ensured that your skin will have all the nourishing and protecting benefits only.

  • Made with only natural ingredients.
  • Doesn’t smudge, flake, or fade.
  • It is water-resistant.

Check On Amazon

10. Good Drugstore Gel Eyeliner: NYX Professional Gel Liner

Cat eye or a smokey eye look, this gel liner works best for both of them. It is made with a soft cream-gel formula which makes it easier to apply. Its ultra-smooth formula makes it easily blend-able and precise for application. This liner glides in easily and doesn’t spread on your face. You can choose from 5 different shades.

  • It is highly pigmented.
  • This liner has a smooth application.
  • It doesn’t cease or fade easily.
  • Available in 5 shades.

Check On Amazon

11. NYX Professional Makeup Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

Available in almost 18 shades, this liquid liner never creates a mess. You have so many options to choose from that none of your looks will go wasted. No matter what dress you have on, you have one perfect shade available for you. Known for its softness and smoothness, this liner pencil is also waterproof.

  • Verified by PETA for being cruelty-free.
  • Smudge-proof and waterproof.
  • Easy to sharpen.

Check On Amazon

12. Youngblood Eye-illuminating Duo Pencil

Made with 100% luxurious minerals, Young Blood guarantees that your skin will never get irritants and will always remain harmless. This dual-end highlighting pencil is perfect for highlighting and brightening your complexion with a matte look. It is made with oil-free formula and is vegan. The best part about this Duo Pencil is that it is suitable for all skin types. 

  • It is made of luxurious minerals. 
  • Suitable for all skin types.
  • Cruelty-free and vegan.

Check On Amazon

13. Covergirl Defining Moment All Day Eyeliner

If you have sensitive eyes, this liner pencil can be your best choice. With an easy glide on application, it fits right into your budget. It is an all-day liner, hence worrying about your makeup fading is completely off the table.

  • It is cruelty-free.
  • Safe for sensitive eyes.
  • Glides on easily.

Check On Amazon

14. 100% PURE Long Lasting Creamy Eyeliner

With the aim of creating products with the highest quality natural ingredients, the founders of 100% Pure wanted to introduce products that will soothe your skin. The products are rich in both plant and fruit pigments. Not only are the products vegan but also cruelty-free. Enriched with Vitamin E, this liner glides on easily in your eyes giving you the much-deserved look.

  • Made with natural ingredients.
  • Cruelty-free and vegan.
  • Enriched with Vitamin E.
  • It is ideal for soothing sensitive skin.

Check On Amazon

15. Kat Von D Kitten Eyes Mini Mascara & Eyeliner

A Vegan product, this Mascara and Eyeliner set by Kat Von D is a perfect combination for your makeup arsenal. The majority of the components, much like the eyeliner, are made up of plant-based fats. The Cake Pencil Eyeliner which has been included in the set is a vegan eyeliner as well, and for an overall coverage in your makeup accessories, this set could very well be worth the bucks paid for it.

  • Waterproof formula.
  • The long-lasting product can be worn for the whole day.
  • Travel-friendly, cruelty-free.

Check On Amazon

Suggested Read: Best Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions

Buyer’s Guide to the Best Cruelty-Free Eyeliner

There are plenty of options when you’re out on the hunt for eyeliners to buy. Depending upon your preferences, and your needs, there are plenty of options and varieties of eyeliners which exist on the market for your purchase, but the problem lies in the making of a definite choice – that part is not so easy since the varieties that exist are too many – pencil eyeliners, liquid and gel eyeliners, etc.

There are just too many. However, many of the features shown are merely gimmicks, so take a careful look at the ingredients, and the below-mentioned pointers, so that you don’t shove your money down the drain.

1. The style of your eyeliner

Smokey, bold cat eye, dramatic, normal, there are so many options available when it comes to the way you apply your eyeliner. Before choosing the right eyeliner for you, you should be clear in your mind about what look you’re going for. If it is a smokey eye or a bold cat-eye look, you must go for an eyeliner which is highly pigmented and liquid too, since liquid liners will easily appear to be thicker on your lids. If you need an eyeliner For normal daily wear use, then choose the ones which are less pigmented.

2. Decide your shade

Although the black shade is the one that steals every girl’s heart. It’s not like other shades are off the market. Shades like grey, brown, or plum give you a soft look. Colors neutral in the shade can be applied for your daily use. For special events, darker shades like violet or blue is likely to make you look even more charming.

3. Determine the finish

Eyeliners can give you a matte look, liquid look, or a glossy look. You should decide which look suits you the best and then accordingly opt for the right eyeliner.

Also Check: Best Cruelty-Free Mascaras in 2020

FAQs Regarding Cruelty-Free Eyeliners

1. Which is the best eyeliner to use?

If you’re a beginner and looking for an eyeliner that is not messy or smears easily, you should go for a pencil eyeliner. They glide easily into your eyes.

2. Which is better a pencil or liquid?

While watching online, applying liquid liners might seem very busy since its smooth and glides on easily but in reality, that’s not the case, especially for beginners. You need a very steady hand for it. On the other hand, pencil liners are easy for everyday use. Since it doesn’t have liquid in it, they are easy to use.

3. How can I put my eyeliner so that it doesn’t smudge?

The best way to ensure this is to first wash your face properly before applying eyeliner. Then moisturize it along with a primer. Before putting the eyeliner, apply concealer in the under-eye area. After this apply the eyeliner.

Also Read: Mac Pro Longwear Fluidline Gel Eyeliner Review


There are many different varieties that have been included by us for you to refer to – so the final choice eventually depends on your preference. For all different types, we have shortlisted the ones which would be best for you, and are all-rounded in terms of features. Keep in mind the type which you are most comfortable with while purchasing, and go on and select one of the above 15 best cruelty-free eyeliners, without any doubts.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here