Best Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions (Reviews & Buyer’s Guide)

best eyeliner for eyelash extensions
best eyeliner for eyelash extensions
We are supported by readers. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

The world is not alien to the obsession which is prevalent amidst women who are keen about their eyelashes and eyebrows. A large portion of time spent in getting ready is usually consumed in getting that perfect eyelash to slay. The companies have capitalised on the need for such perfect eyelashes and the trend of false eyelashes has gained momentum. However, life with extensions is not as easy as it would seem. Although the extra volume to the lashes and the length they provide seem alluring prospect, there are not many eyeliners on the market which will be working well with these lashes.

Some might contrast the extensions completely, or others may just cause them to fall off. While there are plenty of eyelash extensions on the market, this guide is a means to select the best oil free eyeliner

for eyelash extensions, so that you are able to perfectly complement those glamorous extensions. Slay, forever. Get your best oil free eyeliner for eyelash extensions from the list given below.

10 Best Eyeliners for Eyelash Extensions

1. Xtreme Lashes Lash Densifying Liquid Eyeliner

With dual-tip technology and a Precision Tip on one end, and a Style Edge angled tip on the other, this eyeliner enables you to create a subtle everyday look or a dramatic winged look with ease. This eyeliner extension is compatible with all makeup products. Formulated with ingredients that will not cause build-up on the lash line or break down the eyelash extension adhesive bond, this high-performance liquid eyeliner is the catch. It is also easy to remove with no scrubbing and tugging on your gentle eyelids.

  • This eyeliner gives you the perfect wing
  • It is smudge resistant and long-lasting
  • This is enriched with a peptide-rich formula
  • This product is very safe and compatible to use
  • Most importantly, hypoallergenic and dermatologist tested

2. Beauty Garde Oil free Liquid Eyeliner

This oil free liquid eyeliner can be applied anywhere on your eyes or under your eyelids to give you the perfect look of your choice. This oil free eyeliner comes with a precision silicone brush and nib that can be used to apply the eyeliner along with taking care that it doesn’t get into your eyes.

  • Perfect for lash extensions, due to its oil free compound
  • Good for prolonged usage
  • Excessively easy in application
  • Comprises of a unique nib-shaped applicator – for perfect precision
  • A cruelty-free product does not contain Paraben

3. Lavish Liner by Hairgenics Proxena – 2-in-1 Liquid Eyeliner Precision Pen with Eyelash Growth

Infused with eyelash growth serum, this is the perfect eyeliner to create any look in your eyes. It comes with ultra-precise liquid brush tip eyeliner pen dispenses the right amount of liquid liner. Until washed with soap and water, this water-resistant and smudge-proof eyeliner lasts all day long. With revolutionary eyelash growth serum, not only do your eyes look perfect but it will also grow fully and thicker. 

  • This is a Revolutionary liquid eye-liner
  • It is Water-resistant and smudge-proof
  • It comes with a 2-in-1 formula which includes revolutionary eyelash serum

4. AmazonUsLuxury Xtreme Lashes Glideliner Long Lasting Eye Pencil

A combination of the benefits of a liquid liner with the application ease of a traditional pencil, while maintaining compatibility with Extreme Lashes Eyelash Extensions. Eyeliner with silky-smooth gel formula helps in easy and gentle gliding resulting in ultra-pigmented precise and perfectly defined eyes. 

  • It has an Innovative long-lasting gel technology
  • This product Blends upon application, then dries into the smudge-proof finish
  • It is Vitamin-E enriched
  • This eye-pencil is Hypoallergenic and dermatologist tested

5. Alluring Oil Free Liquid Eyeliner for Eyelash Extension

The most woman prefers liquid eyeliner for their perfect glam eyes. Hence this liquid eyeliner is a perfect choice. It is the perfect product for lining and defining the eyes. 

  • It is a Liquid Eye-liner
  • This eyeliner is Oil Free
  • It comes in Black color

6. Novalash LASHliner Pencil with Sharpener for Eyelash Extension

Enriched with deep dark color, this eyeliner helps in creating the lash thicker and beautiful. It can be used with or without the eyelash extensions. This liner comes with a sharpener for longer use. 

  • It is a Super-slim eyeliner pencil with a sharpener included
  • This product is Specially developed for use while wearing eyelash extensions
  • The Precision tip deposits color between the lashes for a bold, dark line
  • It Leaves a head-turning lash line with or without extensions

7. LashX Drama/Line – Smokable Eyeliner in Italian Pigments Long Lasting (Sapphire)

Containing Rich Italian pigments for long-lasting defined eyes, it is a very useful eyeliner for perfect smokey eyes. You can Apply with the perfect eyeliner brush. Drama/Line can be smoked when wet and once it sets will not smudge or smear. It can be removed gently with LAshX Lash Cleanser. Drama/Line is completely safe for eyelash extension wear and is free of fillers, Parabens, Sulfates, Surfactants, Oils and Glycol making it healthy and safe for lashes and eyes. 

  • This Liquid eyeliner is Free of oil
  • Lash X Drama Eyeliners is free of glycol, paraben, and sulfates also.

8. Kat Von D Tattoo Liner Trooper

It is a waterproof liquid eyeliner. 

  • Kat Von D Tattoo Liner Trooper 0.02 oz
  • Black
  • It contains a high-pigment formula, allows the user to wear it all day without smudges.
  • Waterproof, to ensure that it stays put even in a humid environment.

9. Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash 2-in-1 Boosting Eyeliner & Serum, Deep Brown

This particular variant is a liquid eyeliner, and with the extraordinary combination behind the product, the resultant formula helps you reach the base of the eyelashes. As a result, you can enhance the way your lashes look. Equally nourishing, the formula used here mixes serum with the eyeliner, thus keeping the lashes moistened as well. The manufacturing also claims that the product is cruelty-free, and after glancing at the ingredients of the product, it is easy to assume that the product will not be a hindrance to the people whose eyes are sensitive or those who use contact lenses. Another plus – the formula glides on your lashes, for achieving that defined eye.

  • The product claims being approved by the dermatologists
  • A hypoallergenic product, safe for people with sensitive eyes
  • Does not contain the known 150+ ingredients, which could harm the human body

10. Magnetic Liquid Eyeliner Long Lasting

This eyeliner Can dry quickly and is very easy to remove the makeup, suitable to one’s convenience. It is suitable for both beginner practice and professional cosmetic salon. It is easy to draw smooth and fluent lines, which helps create stereoscopic eye makeup. Magnetic liquid eyeliner comes with a Strong magnetic force, which can effectively absorb magnetic false eyelashes.

  • This eyeliner dries itself quickly
  • It is a magnetic eyeliner
  • It is suitable for both beginners and professionals
  • Having a personalized bottle design, it helps in avoiding the outflow

Buyer’s Guide to Buy the Best Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions:

As a buyer, it is a common knowledge that eyelash extensions are an expensive purchase. So, it is equally important that you make the right choice while purchasing these makeup accessories. In doing so, since the variety available in the market is immense, it is essential to keep some parameters in mind while shopping to ensure that you don’t make a mistake. These parameters have been discussed below –

1. Price Range:

The first and foremost consideration is the depth of your pockets – that is, how much are you willing to spend on these beauty accessories. While there are cheap options available on the market, there are some alternatives that could go very high in price, and could literally burn a hole in your pocket. It is up to you to decide if you are willing to spend that high an amount on eyeliners which work along with eyelash extensions because some alternatives which don’t cost as much tend to get the job done as good as the expensive ones.

2. Ingredients:

Secondly, you also need to prioritise the selection of a formula that is oil free. This is primarily because oil components can breakdown the adhesive components which attach your eyelash extensions, and thus, these extensions can fall off more easily. Thus, it is best to select an oil free formula, which requires you to keep a watchful eye on the ingredients of the eyeliners.

3. Smooth Glide:

Additionally, it is also best to consider the formulas which are able to glide smoothly on your extensions. It is common knowledge that the eyeliners which can tug on your lids due to irregularities can lead to the lashes on your eyes falling off, and thus, it is another thing which one will need to keep in mind while examining the products.

Also Check: Mac Pro Longwear Fluidline Gel Eyeliner in Blacktrack – Swatches and Reviews

FAQ’s Related to Purchase of Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions

1. Can eyeliner extension be used alongside a standard eyeliner?

Without a doubt, the eyelash extensions can also be accompanied by eyeliners, but it can’t just be any standard eyeliner, and in order to use the two of them together, you may very well need to replace the eyeliner you already have. Usually used eyeliners i.e. liquid or pencil eyeliners are not the best match with the eyelash extensions, nor are oil liners recommended, since they can cause early loss of eyeliner extensions.

2. When is an eyeliner used before or after completing a fake eyelash?

So as to have a perfect eye, it is always the ideal method that you apply the lashes after the eyeliner has been applied. If this method is not followed properly, there is a very good chance that the liner might fall off from the lashes.

3. Can makeup wipes be used over the eyelash extensions?

When you need to wipe the eyelash extensions, it is always recommended that you use oil free makeup removers, as using the oil free makeup-wipes can pose a hurdle by tugging to the eyelashes.

4. Is it advised to use eyelash-extensions?

Admittedly, it is not possible for everyone to carry the grace that comes along with the eyelash extensions. Simply applying them without doing justifying the worth is only tarnishing their utility. It is only advised for those who can carry them around graciously.

5. Is it possible to prolong the lifetime of eye-lash extensions?

Usually, the life of all the eyelash-extensions is the same, however, there are some things that you can do in order to make your eyelash extensions last longer. These steps are as follows –

  • For the first 48 hours of the use, try to avoid exposure to steam
  • Ensure the usage of cleaning products that are oil free
  • Take care and brush the extensions twice a day
  • Attempt to always sleep on your back

6. Can you wear eyeliner with eyelash extension ?

Yes, ofcourse ! you can wear eyeliner with eyelash extension but it should be an oil-free and eyelash extension safe eyeliner and you need to wear it with extra care and safety.

7. What to Look for in an Eyeliner for Eyelash Extensions?

Whenever you want to buy an eyeliner for eyelash extension, you need to take care of the eyeliner that it should be fake eyelash safe eyeliner and you can check our buying guide also.

8. What About Removing Eyeliner On Lash Extensions?

You can use a cotton bud soaked in a micellar water and pat it gently on your eyelash extensions. Don’t use an oil based, harsh makeup remover and


The market is filled with a variety of best oil free eyeliner for eyelash extensions, but not all of them can be used with eyelash extensions. It is imperative that you sidestep all the landmines where you could select an eyeliner that could potentially ruin your extensions. However, once you have shortlisted the perfect oil free eyeliners for eyelash extensions, from thereon, the sole consideration shall be the utility that any given product has for you, and how much are you willing to spend. There are a variety of products available on the market, and depending on the personal preferences, any of the above options for oil free eyeliners would be a wise decision.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here